After the sex, Jemma helps Maggie to prepare for the party, but says she'll leave before the guests arrive so nobody will mistake Jemma for Maggie's girlfriend. When the decorating is nearly done, Maggie's older sibling Virginia (Electra Rayne) teases Maggie a bit. Virginia is a lesbian, and it seems that she might suspect Maggie has feelings for Morgan.
As Jemma leaves, Lea and Rachel arrive for the party. Maggie greets her old friends, but becomes tongue-tied when Morgan appears... with a girlfriend! Morgan introduces her girlfriend as Kate (Maya Woulfe), and says she hopes it's okay if Kate crashes the party. Maggie is left stunned.
The party gets underway, including a game of Spin The Bottle. But the kissing game causes Maggie to feel even more lonely and heartbroken, and she makes an excuse to sneak off to masturbate. Meanwhile, Lea sneaks off to do much more than kissing with Virginia.
When Maggie returns to the Spin The Bottle game, her heartbreak only gets worse... and when the pizza arrives, a well-intentioned question from the pizza delivery driver (Bree Mills) reminds Maggie even more that this reunion with Morgan has gone all wrong. Can anything salvage this party?